🔍 Comparison Proton Drive vs. Filen Drive: In-Depth Comparison of Secure Cloud Storage in 2024

[MematiMemati is verified member.]

Proton Drive vs. Filen Drive: Comprehensive Comparison​

Feature	Proton Drive	Filen Drive
Privacy	Outstanding: End-to-end encryption (E2EE) for files and metadata ensures full privacy. Based in Switzerland with strict privacy laws.	Outstanding: Comprehensive E2EE, including file metadata. Based in Germany under GDPR regulations.
Security	E2EE protects files, metadata, and file sharing. Password-protected, expiring links add an extra layer of security.	E2EE secures files and metadata. Password-protected, expiring links ensure secure sharing.
Collaboration Tools	Supports collaboration through Proton Docs (Beta), with real-time editing and encrypted sharing.	Collaboration limited to secure file sharing; no real-time editing tools.
Desktop Integration	Native apps for Windows and macOS provide seamless file syncing.	Native apps available for Windows, macOS, and Linux with smooth integration.
Mobile Integration	Fully supported on iOS and Android.	Fully supported on iOS and Android, offering similar functionality.
AI Features	Planned: On-device AI features designed to preserve user privacy.	No AI features; prioritizes simplicity and privacy.
Free Plan	5GB free storage.	10GB free storage.
Paid Plans	200GB: $3.99/month.	200GB: €1.99/month (approximately $2.30).
Encrypted Sharing	Fully encrypted sharing with password protection and expiration dates.	Fully encrypted sharing with similar options for password protection and expiration dates.
Metadata Protection	Metadata is encrypted, ensuring even filenames remain private.	Metadata is encrypted for maximum privacy.
Jurisdiction	Switzerland: GDPR-compliant, governed by strict Swiss privacy laws.	Germany: GDPR-compliant, adhering to stringent EU privacy standards.
Data Residency	Data stored in Europe with redundancy across secure regions.	Data stored in Europe, primarily in Germany, ensuring compliance with GDPR.
Cross-Platform Support	Available across all major platforms with encrypted synchronization.	Fully cross-platform, offering encrypted synchronization on Windows, macOS, Linux, iOS, and Android.
Customer Support	Dedicated, ad-free customer support.	Ad-free support with fast response times.
Data Export	Simple, one-click export process with full encryption.	Easy, fully encrypted export process.
Dark Web Monitoring	Included in premium plans via Proton Sentinel.	Not available.

---

Detailed Analysis of Key Features​

Privacy and Security​

• Proton Drive: Offers end-to-end encryption for both files and metadata, ensuring no one—including Proton—can access your data. Sharing is secure with password-protected and expiring links.
• Filen Drive: Delivers robust security with comprehensive E2EE for all files and metadata, including secure sharing with password-protected and expiring links.

Collaboration Tools​

• Proton Drive: Includes Proton Docs for privacy-focused collaboration, enabling encrypted real-time editing and sharing. While not as feature-rich as mainstream alternatives, it prioritizes security.
• Filen Drive: Collaboration features are minimal, limited to secure file sharing without real-time editing tools.

Pricing​

• Proton Drive: Offers a competitive plan at $5.99/month for 1TB, with an emphasis on privacy and security.
• Filen Drive: More affordable at €4.99/month for 1TB (approx. $5.30), making it an attractive option for cost-conscious users.

Jurisdiction and Data Residency​

• Proton Drive: Operates under Switzerland’s stringent privacy laws, making it ideal for users who prioritize legal safeguards against data access. Data is stored within Europe, ensuring compliance with GDPR.
• Filen Drive: Based in Germany, it benefits from GDPR's robust privacy protections. Data is securely stored in European data centers.

---

Best Use Cases​

1. Proton Drive: Ideal for privacy-focused individuals and businesses requiring secure collaboration tools and advanced encryption, with the added legal protection of Swiss jurisdiction.
2. Filen Drive: Perfect for users looking for an affordable yet secure E2EE cloud storage solution with strong metadata privacy, especially in the EU.

---

Conclusion​

Proton Drive and Filen Drive both excel in privacy and security, offering comprehensive E2EE and robust jurisdictional protections. Proton Drive shines with its collaboration tools and plans, while Filen Drive stands out as a cost-effective alternative without compromising on privacy. Both services are excellent choices depending on user priorities, such as budget, collaboration needs, or advanced privacy requirements.